Maimonides on Reinforcement
Maimonides, a Medieval Jewish philosopher ( 12th century ) and a Torah scholar on the workings of positive reinforcement
”
. Imagine a small child who has been
brought to his teacher so that he may be taught
the Torah, which is his ultimate good because
it will bring him to perfection. However, be-
cause he is only a child and because his under-
standing is deficient, he does not grasp the true
value of that good, nor does he understand the
perfection which he can achieve by means of
Torah. Of necessity, therefore, his teacher, who
has acquired greater perfection than the child,
must bribe him to study by means of things
which the child loves in a childish way. Thus,
the teacher may say, “Read and I will give you
some nuts or figs; I will give you a bit of
honey.” With this stimulation the child tries to
read. He does not work hard for the sake of
reading itself, since he does not understand its
value. H e reads in order to obtain the food. ,
As the child grows and his mind improves,
what was formerly important to him loses its
importance, while other things become pre-
cious. The teacher will stimulate his desire
for whatever he wants then. The teacher may
say to the child, “Read and I will give you
beautiful shoes or nice clothes.” Now the child
will apply himself to reading for the sake of
new clothes and not for the sake of study it-
self. . . . As his intelligence improves still more
and these things, too, become unimportant to
him, he will set his desire upon something of
greater value. Then his teacher may say to
him, “Learn this passage or this chapter, and
I will give you a denar or two.” Again he will
try to read in order to receive the money, since
money is more important to him than study.
The end which he seeks to achieve through his
study is to acquire the money which has been
promised him. When his understanding has so
improved that even this reward has ceased to
be valuable to him, he will desire something
more honorable. His teacher may say to him
then, “Study so that you may become the presi-
dent of a court, a judge, so that people will
honor you and rise before you as they honor
So-and-so.” He will then try hard to read in
order to attain his new goal. His final end then
will be to achieve the honor, the exaltation,
and the praise which others might confer upon
him.
Now, all this is deplorable. However, it is
unavoidable because of man’s limited insight,
as a result of which he makes the goal of
wisdom something other than wisdom itself,
and assumes that the purpose of study is the
acquisition of honor, which makes a mockery
of truth. Our sages called this learning not for
its own sake. . . .”
Reference:
‘Isadore Twersky (Ed.), A Maimonides Reader. New
York: Behrman House, 1972. Pp. 404-407.
Sridhar Mudhan, Board Certified Behavior analyst, India Mobile : +91 9538001515